SafeAssign isn’t safe for students

By  | 11/13/2007 | Filed under: General

The cheerfulness among undergraduates at my institution has transformed suddenly into overt displays of despair and depression. This can only signal one thing: midterm grades are coming in.

Another sign midterms are being graded: the Education Futures access.log has been receiving many referral hits from websites claiming to thwart plagiarism.

Students, please note that submitting your papers on sites such as SafeAssign (by Blackboard) is not safe, and in no way protects your privacy. Why? Because I can read your papers by visiting referral URLs left by your instructors on this site’s log. SafeAssign does nothing to hinder me from reading your work. It’s all open for the world to view. The SafeAssign FAQ states, “Blackboard does not claim any ownership rights on the content submitted to SafeAssign.” So, why do they redistribute it to the world?

A student at the University of Illinois at Chicago’s College of Nursing wrote an outstanding community health assessment of a Chicago neighborhood. I got to read her work in its entirety because SafeAssign has assigned a 7% chance that she lifted the following text from an EF post on China:

Healthy People 2010. (2007). Adults with Congestive Heart Failure as Principal Diagnosis, 1997. National Hospital Discharge Survey (NHDS), Retrieved November 1, 2007, from http://www.healthyPeople.gov/Document/HTML/Volume1/12Heart.htm.

Hozawa, A., Folsom, A., Sharrett A., Chambless L. (2007). Absolute and attributable risks of cardiovascular disease incidence in relation to optimal and borderline risk factors: comparison of African American with White subjects- Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities Study [Electronic Version]. Archives Of Internal Medicine , 167(6), 537-539.

Sharma, S., O’Keefe, SJ. (2007). Environmental influences on the high mortality from colorectal cancer in African Americans[ Electronic Version]. Postgraduate Medical Journal, 83(983), 583-589.

Why SafeAssign thinks there’s a 7% chance she plagiarized that from EF baffles me.

The student gets an A from EF for her outstanding work. SafeAssign gets an F for failing to protect students’ best interests through a shoddy, insecure product.

Post to Twitter Post to Facebook

Comments


About

Dr. John Moravec is a faculty member in the Department of Organizational Leadership, Policy, and Development and the Innovation Studies/Master of Liberal Studies graduate programs at the University of Minnesota. He is the principal of Education Futures LLC; a co-founder of the Horizon Forum, a roundtable on the future of education at all levels; and is the editor of Education Futures. He can be emailed at john@educationfutures.com.

http://www.educationfutures.com/john

Tags: , , , ,

One Response to SafeAssign isn’t safe for students

  1. Garry R. Doty on 12/1/2010 at 11:52

    I totally agree with your assessment of SafeAssign. I recently received a 7% as well. Before I sent the paper through SafeAssign I sent a cover letter stating I was sending it through the system under duress and I did not and do not agree with the terms and conditions. I did not give up my rights just beacuse I could not ‘uncheck’ the box. I would suggest that anyone sending their work through SafeAssign(what a joke) do the same. If you would like a copy of the cover letter, send an e-mail to me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


Related posts

Response from MyDropBox

I just received this response from Max Lytvyn at MyDropBox: I’m sorry for the delayed response. I met with the development team regarding the issue you mentioned. It turned out this was a known issue since this past fall, and we had a fix ready. The fix was not deployed not to introduce any changes [...]


Another critical security flaw with anti-plagiarism software

I’ve found a second critical security flaw with anti-plagiarism software.  This time, it’s with MyDropBox, and the problem is arguably more severe.  Again, private student data and student work are being made available to third parties. I’ve reported the problem to MyDropBox, and will provide more details on this after I hear back from them. [...]


Blackboard announces SafeAssign is safer now

Blackboard Beyond‘s Greg Ritter sent me a note announcing that “the issue [I] experienced with SafeAssign that enabled [me] to gain access to a SafeAssign user’s paper has been resolved. Blackboard released a new version of the SafeAssign central service as well as a new version of the SafeAssign Building Block last Tuesday, November 20.” [...]


A positive nod to Blackboard

I received a call this afternoon from a third-party developer who confirmed the Blackboard Beyond Initiative is working aggressively on a fix for the critical flaw in its SafeAssign product reported at EF on Tuesday. The good news is that student data is no longer being distributed into the wild. This is a huge gain [...]


Redacted post … unredacting next week

After reading yesterday’s post on SafeAssign at least 31 times today, Blackboard Beyond Initiative product director Greg Ritter (who also blogs) called me to voice Blackboard’s objections over sharing information on the software flaw that broadcasts submitted students’ papers across the Internet. I thought a personal call from the company was much better than receiving [...]


About

Education Futures explores a New Paradigm in human capital development, fueled by globalization, the rise of innovative knowledge societies, and driven by exponential, accelerating change. Education Futures is owned and published by Education Futures LLC.